Kazakhstan's Democratic Forces Forum

 

21st Century Pirates: Companies Kaztelecom and Nursat

U.S. State Department has drawn the international public attention to the illegal and nearly pirate practice of Kazakhstan's largest Internet providers, Kaztelecom and Nursat, which deny their users access to the Eurasia web site.

The Human Rights Practices Report: Kazakhstan published on 4 March 2002 in Washington describes the political censorship practiced by these two Internet providers as follows: "Clients of the two largest Internet providers, Kaztelecom and Nursat, periodically were blocked from direct access to the opposition Evrasia Web site, although access was still available through proxy servers. In September human rights monitors alleged that Kaztelecom and Nursat users were unwittingly viewing a "mirror site" of the opposition Cvrasia page. On the "mirror site" users view a page that mimics the original, but without material highly critical of the Government."

Kazakh citizens appear to have fallen victims to the illegal manipulation by the companies Nursat and Kaztelecom who follow the orders of Kazakh secret services. Paying for the ISP's services, their customers in Kazakhstan are provided with poor service. In doing so, these ISPs violate a vital human right to unimpeded access to information. This right is guaranteed by the Constitution of Kazakhstan and provided by many international treaties which the Nazarbayev regime pretends to have accepted but do not observe.

Lots of letters that the Eurasia Information and Analytical Center (IAC) receives from Kazakhstan help to get a clear picture of how cynically and consistently the Nursat and Kaztelecom companies have been violating the Net's most significant ethical standards. Their executives dare not admit the fact of political pressure from the National Security Committee, so they go on lying and denying their interfering with information exchange and their secret censorship practice.

However, it would be wrong to view Nursat and Kaztelecom as the unwilling aides of the Kazakh secret services. Contrary to that, the two providers have been actively involved in the National Security Committee's activities (NSC). For instance, they are responsible for the guilty verdict in the Sergey Musorin's case, who was arrested by the NSC and sentensed to 1 year in prison for demanding a free from censorship and unimpeded Internet access in general, and access to the Eurasia web site in particular.

As we have learnt from Sergey Musorin's letter addressed to the Information and Analytical Center Eurasia, in 2000 he repeatedly turned to Kaztelecom company and demanded that they stop blocking the Eurasia web site and destroy the "mirror site" they had created in its place. As their client, he is entitled to a quality service, said Sergey Musorin.

In reply to his demands, the Almaty NSC Department officials arrested Sergey Nusorin on 3 March 2001. Denis Lemeshko, Almaty secret service officer was in charge of this arrest. The Almaty secret service in question was headed by the President Nazarbayev's son-in-law. Criminal case No. 1310026 was initiated against Sergey Musorin.

To pressure Sergey Musorin, the law-enforcement officials used extrajudicial means including physical abuse. During the trial, Sergey Musorin refused all the evidence he had given in the course of pretrial investigation. Still he was found guilty.

Maxim Petin, Kaztelecom's staff member, was an expert for the prosecution in the trial. He also participated in the search executed at Musorin's apartment. A test shows that 23 days after his computer was seized, certain manipulations were performed with it, says Sergey Musorin. New programs were installed on his computer while the existing were modified. Kaztelecom staff member Petin seems to have performed this to make sure that Sergey Musorin, who defended his rights, was found guilty.

Kazakhstan has now its first political prisoner found guilty on the basis of Internet-related charges. It's disgusting that the ISPs Kaztelecom and Nursat are the accomplices to the authorities and repressive agencies in this shameful case.

We urge the Internet community to boycott the Kaztelecom and Nursat companies by breaking off any contacts with them.

We urge investors and financial institutions not to cooperate with Nursat and Kaztelecom in any form.

We urge journalists and human rights activists specializing in the free information exchange on the Net to take note of the unlawful activities of these two companies.

We urge the U.S. Government and Governments of other democratic states to make it possible for Kazakh citizens to obtain the Internet access free from the Nazarbayev Government control.

IAC Eurasia, www. eurasia.org.ru
05 Mar 2002